Playing the Indian Card

Showing posts with label Tory leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tory leadership. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 08, 2022

The State of the Conservative Race

 


Since more than half of the current membership of the Conservative Party have been recruited through Pierre Poilievre’s website, the strong presumption must be that he is going to win the Tory leadership on the first ballot. It is now unlikely that any Conservative politicians are going to see a future in attacking him publicly; or, indeed, supporting his rivals. We may be at the point of inevitability. 

The strategy of Jean Charest and Patrick Brown until now, of attacking Poilievre with unprecedented venom, now looks very bad for them. Especially for Charest, who has the bigger reputation, and more to lose. Given that Brown reputedly signed up 150,000 new members, Charest looks likely to come no higher than third on the first ballot. That’s especially an embarrassment for someone with his stature. Thinking only in terms of his own political future, I would bow out now, declare my enthusiastic support for Poilievre, and make much of calling for party unity. Even start actively campaigning for Poilievre. He could then look like the kingmaker, and could claim to have made a personal sacrifice for the party. If Poilievre wins the next election, he might hope for an important cabinet post. If Poiiievre loses, he has now paid his dues and would be well-positioned to run as his replacement.

If Charest drops out, will others stay in? Brown might not. Lewis might as well stay on as a spare in case emergency, and to keep it interesting; but will stop attacking the frontrunner. Baber and Atchison might as well stay in, as they were always only in to raise their profiles.

But it’s liable to be a quiet race from here on in.


Sunday, April 10, 2022

Charest Lights Himself on Fire, Hoping to Bring Down the Conservative Party with Him?

 



After this interview, it is clear that if Jean Charest wins the Tory leadership, the party will split. He is actually falsely accusing Pierre Poilievre, Candice Bergan, and Andrew Scheer of breaking the law. They and their supporters could hardly stay in the same party with him.

What is he thinking? Is he only in the race as an agent provocateur or Fifth Column?



Sunday, February 06, 2022

The Early Odds for the Conservative Leadership

 



It is rather odd that Pierre Poilievre has announced for the Tory leadership when he did, on a Saturday, a day when people are liable to miss the news, and when other big news stories are competing for attention. He is also announcing before the date or the rules for the contest have even been set.

The announcement must have been preemptive. His people must have feared someone else might beat him to it and soak up some of his potential support. Who?

Leslyn Lewis, perhaps. But here’s another possibility: Jordan Peterson. Peterson has not dismissed political ambitions. He might or might not have been about to actually declare, but his hints of interest might have started a “draft Peterson” movement.

Peterson might be the only other candidate who stands a chance against Poilievre. Poilievre is a star in question period, and a star in social media. He is fluently bilingual. He is from Ontario, but his rightist politics are in sync with the West. He has cabinet experience. He is eloquent, and has great political instincts.

 It is hard to see who else can go up against him. John Baird has been floated; but Baird just endorsed Poilievre. Brad Wall is not bilingual, and probably not interested. Peter MacKay is still paying off debts from last time.

In theory, given that Poilievre is on the party’s right, there ought to be room for a candidate on the left. But such a candidate probably has no chance of winning. Last time out, Peter MacKay failed to win for the left wing, despite having a far higher profile and far more experience than the three right-wing candidates. This time, the rules have changed to favour the right: from one hundred votes per constituency, the party is going to one member, one vote. That means suddenly most votes are coming from Alberta and the West.

Someone has to run, just to show the flag, to show the party’s diversity, to make it a contest. And as they say, “a week is a long time in politics.” Certainly there are other names being floated. Anything can happen.

But the early line has to be overwhelmingly Poilievre.


Saturday, February 05, 2022

Poilievre Is In

 


I expect this is pre-emptive, to grab the top organizers and warn others on the right not to waste their time and resources.


Monday, March 02, 2020

Decarie: Road Closed


Richard Decarie
The Conservative Party has refused to allow Richard Decarie to run for their leadership.

Decarie has been criticized in the media for public comments that being gay is a choice, and that government health care should not fund abortions. He would surely have had no chance to win, but these are ideas with which the Conservative Party establishment does not want their brand identified.

This is further evidence that the process is being tightly controlled for a pre-ordained result. The elites within the party, whoever they are, do not want things messed up by the voters. It began with the stiff entry criteria, supposedly to avoid as many candidates as they had the last time.

But why was this a problem? Why was it a problem that they had many candidates? What is bad about offering their members a choice?

Someone seems to have gotten to Jean Charest, Pierre Poilievre, Rona Ambrose, and John Baird, in turn, making them some secret offer they could not refuse to clear the aisle for Peter MacKay. For that matter, Andrew Scheer might have been given the same message. His resignation was sudden and unexpected, and came after MacKay signs started showing up at his events. Perhaps someone left a horse’s head in his bed, too.

I did not detect at the time any popular groundswell for the great Peter MacKay. It is not as though he has charisma. It looks more as if he must have powerful friends. Or owners. MacKay does not have a record of honest dealing.

True, the grey eminences also let Erin O’Toole run. But you have to let someone—you need the appearance of a contest. Even the Communists run their dummy alternative candidates. Moreover, in case MacKay stumbles badly, you need a spare.

To me it all makes it highly dubious to vote Conservative federally. They are controlled by special interests, and we do not know who the special interests are. If their motives were admirable, we probably would.

This also makes the Conservatives the very opposite of a populist party, in a time when populism is sweeping the right.

It begins to make them look irrelevant.

Friday, January 31, 2020

Gay Pride and the CPC






Saw a disturbing CBC “Power and Politics” panel on the issue of Tory leadership candidates marching in gay parades. Four panelists; with only Stockwell Day to speak for the Tories. The position one panelist kept repeating, to apparent general agreement, is that this was obligatory or else the politicians were declaring themselves “homophobic.” A more or less direct quote: “it is not enough to show tolerance. You must show that you support and celebrate Gay Pride.”

An odd standard, as Day observed, to apply in other circumstances. Do we really consider politicians who do not regularly attend Yom Kippur celebrations anti-Semitic? Are we now going to?

This new conflation of tolerance with approval is alarming in many ways. If tolerance has no value, and only celebration and support counts, we will only tolerate what we celebrate. This is the most extreme form of intolerance. All views with which you disagree would be silenced.

In the present case, what is not being tolerated is Christians, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, religion, or ethical codes in general—a lot of targets. Celebration, as opposed to tolerance, of “gay pride” is intolerance of all these groups.

Essentially all religious and moral traditions teach that homosexual acts are sinful; but that is even beside the point. All teach that pride and lust are sinful. “Gay Pride” parades are celebrations of pride and lust, at least as explicitly as they are celebrations of homosexual attraction.

Any believing member of any of these religions, or of any other established moral code, cannot in good conscience march in a gay pride parade. Requiring this is excluding them from public life.

It is, perhaps more alarmingly, excluding anyone who sincerely follows any established morality from public life. This is a guarantee of the worst government available.

In sadly only too related news, we see a general furor over obscure leadership candidate Richard Decarie, and demands, including by prominent Conservatives, that he be barred from the race. Because he stated publicly that being gay is a choice.



He said some other things, as well, all perfectly unobjectionable, but this is the one the headlines have fixed upon.

Yet “being gay” self-evidently is a choice, in the most basic sense. While I may and may not have a choice concerning who sexually attracts me, I obviously have a choice as to whether or not to have sex with them. Otherwise, there could be no objection to rape.

Being “gay” is obviously a choice in another sense as well. If not, why do gays themselves speak of a “gay lifestyle”? There is an element of choice in being “gay,” in the minds of “gays” themselves. “Gay” does not equate to “being attracted to members of the same sex.”

As to whether one chooses to be attracted to those of the same sex—that too is unclear. We do not know, and it is deceitful to insist that we do. As recently discussed in this space, the traditional view, right up to Freud, is that we can control and are therefore fully responsible for our lusts.

We live in an increasingly intolerant age.

Thursday, November 28, 2019

Mrs. Warren's Impression




Elizabeth Warren’s support down in the Estados Unidos is visibly collapsing, and it seems to be because she rolled out the details of her health plan.

Meanwhile, Bernie Sanders’s support is steady and now stronger, with a more radical and expensive plan.

The problem seems to be that Warren’s plan now looks like a fudge. She’s delaying the costly part of it three years to mask the real expense. And, of course, she has resisted even saying that taxes would have to go up to pay for it.

This illustrates Andrew Scheer’s problem here in Canada. It is not that his rather mainstream views are too radical. It is that he seems to be fudging. He looks dishonest. Not a good look.

I’m tempted to say the electorate has become too smart for that. But really, they are not that smart. Elizabeth Warren’s dishonesty has been obvious to all at least since her DNA test results. Biden’s has been obvious since the 1980s. It usually takes a while.

This is a big reason for the Tories not to turn now to Peter MacKay. No politician has shown more blatant dishonesty than he, in his pact with David Orchard long ago to take the PC leadership. Electing him would be like grabbing at a grenade with the pin missing.