Playing the Indian Card

Showing posts with label Canadian Parliament. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian Parliament. Show all posts

Monday, October 02, 2023

On Nazis and Forgiveness

 

Ex-House Speaker Anthony Rota

Friend Xerxes has come out in qualified defense of the Canadian Parliament applauding for a former Nazi last week.

To begin with, he makes the valid historical point that Hunka’s actions might not have been that unforgivable, given the history of the Western Ukraine. Barring evidence of his participation in specific war crimes.

But Hunka is not the real issue; and there is a valid distinction between forgiving his actions and giving them a standing ovation.

More generally, Xerxes objects to calling anything “unforgivable.”

I agree that “unforgivable,” if it was used, is the wrong term. Apparently the NDP House Leader, at least, used the word. Nothing is unforgivable in principle. The term should never be used, here or elsewhere. “Intolerable” or “unacceptable” would be proper—requiring apology, atonement and then forgiveness.

What was intolerable, to be precise, was the Canadian parliament giving a standing ovation to someone for fighting for Nazi Germany, during a state visit by the president of Ukraine. This looked to the enemies of Canada and of Ukraine like an endorsement of Nazism and an admission that the Ukrainians have Nazis among them, and they are officially embraced. Fitting perfectly with Putin’s justification for his invasion.

This being so, the people of Canada, the government of Ukraine, the Jews, the Poles, Canadian veterans, and the people of the world, are entitled to a full investigation and a clear explanation of how this happened, and apologies and atonement all round. Nothing really personal against Hunka.

The Speaker of the House has taken full responsibility, claimed it was due to his ignorance, and resigned. But this leaves too many unanswered questions. He announced to the House that Hunka fought against Russia in World War II. Anyone who knows the basics of that conflict would have known that meant he also fought against Canada; how could that not be a concern? How could that not raise further questions? Is it credible that the Speaker, and those in his office, were so ignorant? How was Hunka not also vetted by the security services, in the context of a state visit?

The situation was intolerable; meaning we cannot look the other way. We must investigate. It is likely that more people must lose their jobs, to make it clear that Canada does not support or endorse Nazism. It would actually make most sense if the entire parliament resigned and submitted themselves to the judgement of the people.


Wednesday, September 27, 2023

Flowers for Hitler

 


These are strange days in Canada, getting stranger daily. The House of Commons recently gave two standing ovations to an unrepentant Nazi, a former soldier in the Waffen SS, of a unit implicated in some of the worst atrocities of the Holocaust. How did it happen?

I think we can take as given that they did not mean to do it. Once one member stands and begins to applaud, all other members will do likewise, unless they have some clear reason not to. For they are going to be grilled by the media and interest groups over why they did not. 

The Speaker, of the House Anthony Rota, has taken full responsibility, but claiming he did not realize just who he was introducing.

This sounds improbable; incredible. This was in the context of a state visit by Vladimir Zelensky, president of the Ukraine, in a time of war. Were guests not vetted by security services? It would be insane not to do so. Even without security services, the simplest of online searches would have revealed who Yaroslav Hunka was. Just the fact that he fought against Russia in the Second World War, the reason he was honoured by speaker Rota, was incriminating enough.

Moreover, some have pointed out from the video of the moment that Rota falters a bit when he reads that Hunka fought against Russia in the Second World War. His eyebrow goes up. He seems not to have been aware of this, and suspects something. Yet it is too late to pull out; he continues.

He is reading someone else’s words, and is surprised.

Lisa Raitt noes that, if some war veteran is introduced to Parliament, his regiment is cited, and where it fought. Details are omitted in Hunka’s case; whoever wrote Rota’s remarks seems to have known they would be a problem.

Rota has taken the fall; it does not seem possible that he was responsible.

Was it someone in his office setting him up? If acting alone, I don’t see the motive.

At the same time, it does not seem possible that the Trudeau government was trying to slip this by. They had little to gain by doing so—perhaps an extra pander to the Ukrainian-Canadian lobby, on top of the cheque to Zelensky--and too much to lose.

So whodunit?

It seems to me it must have been the security service itself; or the deep state, acting collectively. They must have vetted Hunka, known who he was, and set the government, Rota, and parliament up.

The security services seem to have turned on Trudeau; it was they who leaked the information about Chinese interference in Canada. Those leaks seemed coordinated and systematic, keeping the issue hot for week after week. This may be a continuation of the same campaign.

Why is the Trudeau government not pointing the finger at the real culprits?

Because the security services are already too powerful. As Scott Adams predicted, or observed, they were inevitably going to seize power in any government. The Deep State is and always has been the Liberals’ key constituency. The Liberals cannot turn on them.

At the same time, the Deep State may not need the Liberals. They may own the Tories too. Best, then, to make it clear to the Grits just who is boss. Pull the plug on the little jerk. And their recent leaks and this incident too, seem tailored to discredit parliament and our democracy itself, not just the current government.

It is eerie, as well, that the revelation that there are Nazis living peacefully and with honour in Canada also dovetails well with recent charges from the Indian government, made in response to Trudeau’s attacks over the murder of Najjar Singh. How far does this coordination spread?